We Have a Winner! The Fishing Story Contest

We Have a Winner! The Fishing Story Contest

by | Sep 10, 2020 | 2020 Season

Summer 2020 Fishing Story Contest

10

SEPTEMBER, 2020

What’s the next best thing to actually going fishing? A good fish story…

We asked our guests to provide some fuel for our lack of fishing this summer by way of a Fishing Story Contest. We had many great tales submitted from sea turtles, to cuttthoat, walleye and of course pike! Thank you to all who took the time to share what was happening at the end of your line this summer. Keep an eye out, there might be a surprise in your mail box…

So here they are, in order, the top three fishing stories of Scott Lake guests during their 2020 summer.

The winner earned a ticket for one, anywhere on the flyout map he wants to go.

Both runners up earned themselves a 1 hour massage on us next summer.

Winner: Scott Bixby, TX

7″ Brook Trout ( I have big hands)

August 16: Here’s how it started out. Struck by a wicked case of covid cabin fever in Texas, I decided to try and substitute for our annual August Scott Lake trip with a trek to Colorado.

Half-way through the 14 hour drive, the idea seemed less attractive…it’s never made sense to me why I travel a thousand miles and then bushwhack another 6, in pursuit of a creature with the brain the size of the pea, that usually outsmarts me. But I forged on.

My normal fishing rivers in these parts were desperately low and warm. The trout tend to sleep in these conditions anyway so I elected to climb to higher ground and see if I could catch all four species of trout that hang out in Colorado. I climbed up 1000 feet (okay I drove) to the Flattops Wilderness outside of Yampa, Colorado to the headwaters of the Yampa river. The natives originally called it the bear river, but that’s a longer story. Anyway, I restricted myself to dry flies only to try and catch ‘em the old fashioned way. The challenge with the section of river I chose was the density of willows, scrub and fallen timber I had to conquer to even get within casting distance of the water. I’m too old for this crap, but in for a penny, in for a pound.

After losing my water bottle and most of my patience, I arrived at the river. The water was much higher than I expected… violently foaming over boulders, and looking a lot less fishy than Google Earth had advertised.

But, I wasn’t going bail now, without at least taking a whack at it. First cast I hit some fast water with a caddis and caught this cool little guy exactly where he shouldn’t have been. I don’t know how he even saw the fly through the foam, or had the guts to rise into the torrent of surface flow for it, but that was his choice. A cute little guy and I checked the box for species one.

“It’s never made sense to me why I travel a thousand miles and then bushwhack another 6, in pursuit of a creature with the brain the size of the pea, that usually outsmarts me. But I forged on.”

Colorado River Cutthroat

 

Cutthroats are not the biggest trout but they are my favorite. I don’t know who designed these things but I find their cosmetics breathtaking. I took a pic on the shore to show off the full color. He’s back in the river ‘tho healthy and happy.

So species two under the belt, I searched for pools that might hold a something else. Then this guy was lured in by my miserable presentation.

Kind of a goofy looking fish with his big mouth but whatever. I caught a bunch more rainbows that day but taking photos with an Iphone by yourself is treacherous enough, and I had the proof of species 3.

So now all I needed was a brown trout. I was getting tired and the sun was getting lower in the sky and I was getting thirsty if you know what I mean. So I started the trek back down the river to my starting point, knowing full well that I was out of cell range and might be found by bow hunters in October if I messed it up.

About halfway down I found a big deep pool that I had somehow missed on the way up. I managed to tightrope along a fallen tree to about midway across the river. (I am smart enough to not wade through boulders into 4 foot deep rushing water, but not smart enough to not try and balance on a mossy log.)

I made frankly the best presentation of the day with a super dry fly across the flat, glassy eddy. Boom! Now all I had to do was somehow get this fish to my net. I hadn’t really thought about that part before the cast. I fell, but of course cared a lot less about sacrificing my health vs. losing a fish.

It wasn’t glamorous but I got him in the net.

And there he was, a nice little Brown Trout to round out the species hunt. I took a ridiculous photo perching my IPhone on some junk by the side of the river. But it’s proof nevertheless.

After a long hike back to the car, I pulled off my waders and boots, and took down my rod tossing them into the back of the car a lot less carefully than I had that morning when I left the house.

I was tired but content, and pretty proud of myself for wrangling all four species. Then I grinned looking down looking at the logo on the fishing shirt I had chosen for that day.

So that’s the story. No trophys…but a great day in the wilderness doing what I love.

The only thing that was missing was the comradery of Poacher & Curtis, and all of you at Scott Lake Lodge.

And a healthy serving of Super Chips.

Runner Up: Amy Blackstone, SD

West Slope Cutthroat Trout

Caught on the fly

Even though we watched the news to see when the boarder might open and texted constantly to find out what everyone’s heard… ultimately, COVID put a halt to our fishing trip to Scott Lake Lodge. This was such sad news… hadn’t we been good for the past 3 months? Didn’t we use our hand sanitizer enough? Did we not hoard enough toilet paper???? To have my favorite trip forbidden truly felt like a punch in the stomach. You see, I love to fish. Not just fish, but to spend time outdoors, with good friends, on the water and in the lodge, toasting the trophies of the day and drooling over some good ‘ol fish porn.

When we go fishing, Jim always fly fishes and I tend to use a spinner or bait caster. I’ve tried fly fishing but just haven’t had the time to truly work on it. Well guess what? We’ve sure got the time now!

Traditionally, we celebrate my June Birthday at Scott Lake. This year, we were with friends at a lake and Jim showered me with all the gifts a girl could want…. waders, wading boots, tackle and the promise to indoctrinate me into the addiction otherwise known as fly-fishing.

So, over the fourth of July we drove 12 hours to Missoula Montana (still social distancing) packing lunches and sleeping in the truck, all so we could float the Bitterroot river and I could fly fish for trout!

Just being able to float and enjoy the beautiful outdoors was rejuvenating, but to also gain a skill that I’ve only watched others do made this time so much more meaningful.

We were at Kelly Creek, Idaho (from the movie, A River Runs Through It); when it happened; Wading in the fast waters, casting, a perfect loop, the remote gorgeous setting and watching a big west slope cutthroat trout take the fly. Everything at the moment came together.

Don’t get me wrong, I still have a lot to learn, but after fooling some cutthroats I know the grayling stand no chance and I’ll resolve to catch at least one trophy pike on the fly if Jim will let me use the front of the boat…a matter that is still under negotiation.

Thank goodness Jim has the patience to deal with this left-handed, determined angler.

Runner Up: Valarie Strobel, FL

My mom and I have never fished before we got invited to go to Scott Lake a few years ago by my dad. Yet, my mom somehow made it to the 100 club before anyone else in our family. Therefore, us girls believed we could tackle this sport and that’s when we found ourselves floating down the Gunnison River in Colorado fly fishing. Our guide was not nearly as funny as the guides we’ve had in Canada (shoutout to Biff), but he would do.

Before we jumped into the raft for our float trip down the river the guide asked if we had ever fly fished before, the answer was no, and it was met with complete silence. Pretty awkward if you ask me, but we had to reassure him we knew how to fish, and I even showed off some pictures of our Northern Pike and Lake Trout.

When people say fly fishing takes time and patience they’re not lying. About halfway through our four-hour reserved time we had yet to catch anything. It was cold and rainy and nonstop casting that our hands were cramping badly. Yet, there was no time for a break because we were on a mission of trying to catch rainbow and brown trout.

Losing hope by the minute and after a few castings gone wrong (like when my mom hooked the guide in his hat) I finally was able to hook the fish and reel in the most beautiful rainbow trout. Gleaming with joy I couldn’t believe I had finally caught a trout on a fly. In that moment I could feel the high of fishing (and it wasn’t just because I was in Colorado).

The next two hours passed quickly and there were many trout caught that I felt I was now a pro angler (or at least better than my dad and brother at fly fishing). This past week was when my family and I were supposed to be in Canada, but not everything can go according to plan. That’s when my mom and I had the opportunity to go fish in Colorado we took it because we needed our dose of fishing for the year. This will hopefully hold us over for a bit until we find our way back to Scott Lake next year.

The Great Canadian Happy Hour Podcast

The Great Canadian Happy Hour Podcast

by | Apr 8, 2020 | 2020 Season, Island Life

While up at the lodge this month the team discussed keeping in touch with our Scott Lake Lodge family now more than ever in these difficult times. So we started a podcast! Tune in to the first couple episodes as Happy Hour conversations…similar to summer at the lodge…cover a variety of topics.

We hope this is a way to capture the stories, history of the lodge and the people that make it so special. We’ll talk outdoors, fishing, hunting and generally have some laughs.

Let us know what you’d like to hear and be sure to tune in and SUBSCRIBE! Leave us a 5 star rating too if you like it!

LISTEN ON APPLE PODCASTS

LISTEN ON SPOTIFY

LISTEN ON GOOGLE PODCASTS

LISTEN ON STITCHER

STAY SAFE ALL!

Tackle Tips

Tackle Tips

by | Mar 15, 2020 | gear

The most important tip: keep it simple. Almost everyone brings far more tackle and gear than they need.

While you don’t need to bring a single rod, reel or lure, we realize that planning and packing for a fishing trip is a big part of the excitement and the experience. We will not deny our customers that aspect of a northern adventure.
So, you do have options but keep in mind that the Lodge has for your complimentary use high quality Shimano rods and reels to cover all of our fishing opportunities. Each guide has an arsenal of great rods and reels: two each of open-face spinning, ultra-light spinning, low profile casting, heavy duty trolling, and fly rod rigs in both 4-weight for grayling and 9-weight for pike and trout. We have you covered. We also have a well- stocked tackle shop on the island with all the right lures and flies for our lakes. The lodge does not provide any terminal tackle (lures, flies or leaders) however we’ve put together a list of our most popular lures here for those that want to start shopping now. Keep in mind as you sort through your personal gear that Scott Lake pike and trout are plentiful, hard fighting and fearless, but they are not particularly selective feeders. Most anglers end up using maybe a half-dozen different lures or flies during their trip.

First, A Little About Our Fish

PIKE

Northern pike are found throughout Canada and the northern parts of the United States. With light spots over a dark background and a brilliant green to olive-green dorsal area, the northern pike is a striking fish. A voracious predator, pike are well known to attack almost anything alive, including small muskrats, ducklings, loon chicks, mice and about anything in the lake that isn’t big enough to eat them. A rule of thumb with pike is that they will kill and eat anything up to two-thirds their own size. Typical below the surface pike prey would be leeches, burbot, lake cisco, whitefish, lake trout and yes, smaller pike.

Our pike spawn as soon as the shallow marshy areas are ice free, usually in late May. Since this is typically a time when the main lake is still ice covered, we have never observed the spawning process at Scott. It lasts only a few days. The fertilized eggs will attach to vegetation and hatch into fry in a week to two weeks. The fry will live off their egg sacks until they start swimming and feeding on zooplankton and insect larvae. From tiny fry some real monsters, in the 30-pound range, will emerge some thirty or forty years later. Due to the cold waters and relatively low productivity (a measure of the “living things” in the water) pike growth rates at Scott are very slow, but Scott pike are long lived. In warmer, southern waters the maximum life span might hit 10 to 12 years. At Scott and in similar waters that age span will approach forty years for pike. In 2001 a group of fishery biologists from the British Columbia Institute of Technology in Vancouver conducted field studies as part of lodge funded research to determine the age structure of our pike population. Since accurate aging is a fatal process, we did not harvest trophy pike but we did keep some small and mid-sized pike to get aging data. Their research confirmed a very slow growth rate. Five-year-old pike were only 18-22 inches in length. At ten the average Scott pike is only 28”. One 13-year-old was only 29”. Our big fish (the 40-50 inchers) are as old as many of our anglers. That’s the reason why catch and release in far northern waters is so critical in preserving a quality fishery. Let them go and watch them grow. We’ve been watching for over two decades and due to the strict catch and release program our fish are getting bigger. Scott Lake and the flyout lakes are natural systems: nothing has happened here since the glaciers left about 8,000 years ago. There has been no stocking of any lakes and no introductions of any exotic species. These lakes are at their natural carrying capacity with fish that rarely see a lure.

Lake Trout

The lake trout really isn’t a trout at all. Technically it’s a char, like the arctic char, Dolly Varden or brook trout. Whatever you call it, the laker is a remarkable fish, probably the hardest fighting and strongest of all freshwater fish, including some tough customers like the peacock bass, the tiger fish or the golden dorado. Hooked in shallow water on standard pike gear, the lake trout has incredible stamina. They just don’t quit.

The laker’s deeply forked tail provides it with the tool for tremendous speed, making a rainbow trout or black bass seem like slugs. With that great speed, lake trout can catch just about whatever they want. Their primary forage is the lake cisco, whitefish and smaller trout—yes, another cannibal. Many trophy lakers have been caught on Scott and on flyout lakes with the tails of whitefish still sticking out of their mouths. At Scott we have yet to try a saltwater lure too big for big trout.
When casting or trolling for lakers, a fast-moving lure is usually the best bet. You cannot reel fast enough to get your lure away from a lake trout that wants it. Lake trout in the far north develop beautiful markings when they approach the September spawning period. The fin edges of males turn a bright white and both males and females change color dramatically. The basic silver-sided trout of summer add bright red/orange fish and usually get a darker brown/gold appearance with bright spots. The trout at Scott and other high latitude lakes do not spawn every year. Only about a third of the females spawn every year with a typical female spawning only every two to four years. That’s why in the shallow spawning reefs in September large numbers of smaller males will be swarming the rocks looking for fewer number of females. On Scott most of the spawning (this has been observed) occurs in the second week of September on rocky reefs with a depth of only one to three feet. It’s a wild time to fish for lakers. Actually, anytime is a great time to catch these magnificent fish. While we don’t have world record potential lake trout, we have caught lake trout approaching 50 pounds.

Grayling

For many Scott guests a trip to the north is not complete without a flyout to catch some arctic grayling – a true icon of the far north. Grayling are delicate, beautiful fish well suited to ultra-light spinning tackle or light (4-or 5- weight) fly rods. The grayling flyouts from Scott are all rivers or the short connections between lakes. In these shallow areas there are few if any lake trout or pike, so grayling can survive and thrive.

Grayling are spring spawning fish that feed almost entirely on insects. Most of the time grayling are feeding underneath the surface on the larval stage of a bug’s life. Black flies, mosquitoes, caddis flies and stone flies, either on the surface or below, provide most of the protein for grayling but the larger ones will eat small baitfish. That doesn’t mean that grayling will not take dry flies. Grayling are fantastic dry-fly fish, especially in warm weather. You do not have to see an insect hatch to fish grayling with dries. Try dry flies first, even with spinning tackle (a small bobber gives enough weight to throw the flies). There is something very special about watching these miniature sailfish raise to a drifting fly. They often catch anglers off-guard through, jumping for the fly but taking it on the way down. Wait until you feel the fish before lifting the rod. In cold fronts nymphs may be needed but a grayling caught on light tackle is a wonderful fish hooked either above or below the surface.

Tackle

Spinning and Casting Rods/Reels

If you are bringing your own rods and reels make sure they are heavy enough to handle big fish. We have had a lot of guests bring their soft-tipped walleye rods which just can’t set the hook on the hard mouths of our pike. We also want a heavy enough rod to bring in the fish in a relatively short period of time to prevent literally fighting a fish to death. Typically, these will be . The Shimano Terramar 7′ MH series is the rod of choice at Scott,, a Medium-Heavy Fast Action model. But don’t buy one: we have them. The Terramar bait-casting rods are also excellent if you want to use casting reels. Again, we have them. Most importantly you need a stiff enough rod to handle strong test lines. We use 30lb braided line (Power Pro or Suffix 832) on our spinning and casting reels and 65lb for the trolling reels. We love Shimano reels and have a wide variety of them. Again, for spinning and casting rigs make sure the reel can handle at least up to 30# line. For leaders, we like to suggest that you just buy them at the lodge. We’re not trying to run up your bills. We just have learned not to trust many brands, most without the cross-locked snaps. We have custom-made titanium leaders that hold up to the savage hits of northern pike. If you do bring leaders, they should be “muskie” leaders.

Lures

What to use at the end of that line? Fishing lures can be compared to the fashion industry. There is always something new, but not necessarily better. For pike, the Mepps #5 with or without a bucktail has been catching big pike for decades as has the Johnson Silver Minnow. A very popular spinner at Scott is the Blue Fox Vibrax #5 or #6 in gold. Another great spinner is the Buchertail 500 series in gold/red or black/orange. Even the old school red and white Daredevils will still entice a hungry pike. But not all the pike are always hungry. If you run into those, you need to get more subtle.

Over the past ten years, plastics have been moving to the top of our guide’s and many angler’s tackle trays. At the very top of the tray at Scott will be the Storm Wildeye Pike in the 4”, 5” and 6” size. It’s been a killer. So has the Savage Hybrid Pike in the 7” size. The Berkley Havoc Grass Pig in 5” size with the deadly 7/0 Trokar screwhook is another winner. Other great plastics include the Svartzonker McRubber 5” Paddle Tail and the Savage 3D Burbot. This list could go on and on but like with rods and reels keep it simple. The fish of the far north rarely require many lure changes. Accurate casting and presentation for sight-casting opportunities (most of our big pike chances) is much more important than the lure.

For our big lake trout, we have narrowed down our choices to around a half-dozen. All our guides have the 4.5” and 5.5” Lucky Strike spoons in their box. It’s our #1. The big Daredevil Husky Sr still brings home some fatties as does the classic Williams Whitefish C90. There are some guides who swear by the T-60 Flatfish, but other guides swear at it. There are also times when jigging is the way to go. A basic 3 or 5-ounce white bucktail jig will do the job or the massive but effective 11- ounce Bondy Bait. It’s hard to go too big. Years ago, we had a body shop make some giant spoons over a foot long. They worked. As with all decisions about tackle just listen to YOUR guide’s advice. All our Scott guides are in their second or third decade of fishing northern waters. Go with their instincts not something you read in a fishing magazine.

For grayling, the ultra-light spin angler doesn’t need many tools. The 1/8th ounce Panther Martin has long been a favorite. (The small Mepps spinners will work but it takes a foot of two of retrieve to get their blades moving—go with the Martins.) Any small rubber jigs in the 1/8th ounce will work well. Things that work well for crappies or stream trout will work for grayling. We have a selection of grayling lures at our shop.

Fly Fishing

The rod choice for pike on the fly is easy—go with a 9-weight. As an Orvis Endorsed Lodge, our complimentary rods are 9-weight Helios and Clearwater. The Clearwater is more forgiving to the beginning fly anger and the Helios is an absolute weapon! In the hands of a skilled angler, an 8-weight will work but bringing a heavy fish that last three feet to the net has snapped more than a few eights. If it’s late in the season when throwing heavy sinking lines is in the mix, then having a ten is a good option. For lines, floating will be the right choice for most of the time and most of the season. In a cold front however, pike just sink down to deeper (and counter intuitively) warmer water. Then you want at least an intermediate sinking line. Our favorite is the Scientific Anglers Sonar Titan Full Intermediate but there are many great brands with intermediate and full sink lines. In general, June and early July will be nothing but floating and the balance of the season will be a mix of floating and various sinking lines. For grayling go with a four or five weight rod with a floating line. For lakers, your pike gear is perfect.

Flies

Even more than spin or bait-casting anglers fly anglers tend to obsess about what’s on the end of their line. Fly boxes are always overflowing with flies of every description and color. Well, for pike at Scott Lake it’s quite safe to trim those boxes way down. You might need to adjust the size of your flies to the conditions (mainly water temperature dictated) but the patterns are pretty simple. You will need a bunch of leech patterns in various sizes. Black has always been the number one favorite, but any color, well presented, will trigger a strike. And you need a variety of baitfish patterns: the basic Lefty’s Deceiver in black, red/white or chartreuse will always work as will the Whistler (one of our best-selling flies) and Clouser in the same colors. Bring a few top-water offerings as well. Nothing is more exciting that watching a mouse pattern or gurgler disappear in a violent explosion. Overall, presentation is far more important than style or color. Get your fly well in front of the fish (four to six feet unless it’s moving then make it ten to twenty feet), make it move and hang on. Our fly wall at the lodge will provide all you need at prices far less than most fly shops. For the all-important bite tippet there are many options. Our favorite is the Surflon Mirco Supreme made by American Fishing Wire Company which we sell, but Rio makes a good Pike/Musky wire and Scientific Angler has a great Predator tippet. Don’t play around with even heavy hard mono as a bite tippet. Our experience is that the smaller pike will slice off even the toughest 80 and 100# test mono. Stay with wire. Pike’s teeth are not just numerous; they are serrated.

For lake trout the Whistler seems to be the top fly both spring and fall, but Deceivers work well too. Our fly anglers get quite a few lake trout early and late in our season while they are fishing for pike. In June, lakers are cruising around in shallow water all over the lake. It’s an opportunistic sight fishing game. The key is a long cast and a very fast strip. You can’t strip too fast. Make it as long a cast as possible though since lakers have a pronounced habit of following before hitting. Just don’t stop the strip or the laker will quickly disappear. Late in our season (the last few days of August and early September) lake trout move into shallow water again; this time to spawn. If the water temperature is low enough (around 50 degrees F) our final group or two can have an incredible lake trout experience fishing our many rocky spawning reefs. Any baitfish pattern will work then.

For our grayling fly fishing we have a surefire program. There are only two flies that work for grayling: those that float and those that don’t. It’s an old lodge joke but it indicates that fly patterns are not critical. Just keep your dries rather small (8- 12). Adams, Royal Wulff, Elk Hair Caddis, Humpies, Black Gnat, small hoppers all work well. In a cold front go to nymphs like a Pheasant Tail beadhead, any dark colored stone fly nymph or a standard woolly bugger. Nymphs can be fairly large (6-10). Grayling are active fish found in low “protein” rivers. They look for your fly. This isn’t a match the hatch process or what’s often termed “technical” fishing. This is fun fishing. Just enjoy it.